The Pen

Trusted Westminster Presbyterian Church Administrator and Wife Charged with $1.2M Theft from Church

[Harry Funk | The Almanac] Westminster Presbyterian Church’s long-time administrator is accused of diverting more than a million dollars from the Upper St. Clair church for use by himself and his wife.

Following a lengthy investigation that turned up numerous instances of fraud, including a telephone call to a fake auditor, David Earle Reiter, 50, was arraigned Feb. 19 on multiple felony charges in connection with stealing more than $1.2 million from the church at 2040 Washington Road.

His wife, Connie Jo Reiter, 44, has been charged with two felonies. The South Park couple are scheduled to appear for their preliminary hearings at 1 p.m. Feb. 28 before District Justice Ronald Arnoni.

Jackelyn Weibel, a detective with the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office, filed the charges Feb. 15 in which she detailed a sustained history of deceit that finally unraveled in November, according to court 

David Reiter had served as Westminster’s administrator since 2001, handling all aspects of the finances for the church, including payroll, transfers between accounts, paying vendors and bank reconciliations. Three months ago, according to Weibel, the treasurer of Westminster’s board of directors contacted the Rev. Jim Gilchrist, the church’s senior pastor, about issues involving the church’s supposed auditing firm, Sisterson & Co.

“While the treasurer told Gilchrist that he had already spoken to Drew Harrison, the church’s assigned auditor from Sisterson & Co., on the telephone, he had been asking Reiter to set up a face-to-face interview with Harrison,” Weibel stated in the affidavit. “He told Gilchrist that Reiter had repeatedly made excuses as to why Harrison could not meet with him. The treasurer finally called Sisterson & Co. and asked for Harrison, only to learn that there was no auditor by that name employed at the company.”

The “Harrison” on the call actually was David Reiter, who impersonated an auditor, according to court documents.

When Gilchrist spoke with Reiter on Nov. 28, he allegedly admitted to Gilchrist that he had been stealing from the church’s bank account for 10 to 12 years, saying he did so “to make things better at home,” according to the affidavit.

Weibel said a review of a bank account the Reiters had with PNC Bank revealed numerous large deposits each month, starting in December 2011, marked as “payroll Westminster Pres,” and the unauthorized transfers added up to $979,406.64 through November.

Reiter also had his own Bank of America credit card for legitimate church expenses.

“A review of these records showed hundreds of non-church expenses, such as sporting goods, baseball school, medical expenses, musical instrument rentals, concert tickets, gasoline, car washes, Pandora, Starbucks, Sirius XM Radio,” totaling $229,316.66, Weibel wrote in the affidavit.

Another $18,700 in checks issued by the church was deposited into the Reiters’ account, Weibel said.

“Connie Reiter signed numerous checks on the account, and it appears that many of the debit charges were made for items she would have purchased, such as scrapbook supplies, groceries and other personal expenses,” Weibel said. “These bank records do not contain any deposits that would reflect that Connie Reiter was employed at any time between December 2011 and November 2018. Records show that there were no other legitimate sources of income deposited into this account.”

The couple, according to the affidavit, used the money “to pay for numerous vacations to Walt Disney World, Cedar Point, Hersheypark, King’s Island, as well as other camping excursions. Other expenses included music lessons for the Reiter children, numerous restaurants and fast food establishments, scrapbooking supplies, groceries, vehicle repairs, Apple iTunes, Pittsburgh Pirates tickets and concessions, medical expenses, pet care and supplies, credit card payments, along with insurance, vehicle and utility bill payments.”

[Editor’s Note: This article was written by Harry Funk and originally published at The Almanac. Title changed by P&P.]